Chamilia
vs. Pandora
For
my first case, I’ve chosen Minneapolis-based jewelry company Chamilia’s
infringement on Danish manufacturer Pandora. The case states that Chamilia
infringed on Pandora’s “prevent bunching” bracelet design. Chamilia’s charms
are made with irreversible locks that allow a person to lock their charm in
place on a bracelet to prevent bunching. Pandora has designed a bracelet with
built-in retainers that allow their charms to hang spaciously and prevent
bunching. On August 8, 2008, District Judge Catherine Blake ruled that Chamilia
did not infringe on Pandora’s design. I agree with this decision, because both
designs serve the same purpose, but are handled with different mechanics.
R&L
Merchandise vs. Alex and Ani
My
next case deals with expandable bangle bracelets. The plaintiff, R&L
Merchandise is suing the defendant Alex and Ani, LLC for patent
non-infringement on their expandable bangle bracelet design. According to
R&L Merchandise, their unique stretch bangle design was stolen by Rhode
Island company, Alex and Ani. In this lawsuit there were a lot of similarities.
Both companies sell bangle bracelets and they also sell charms for those
bracelets. On November 9, 2004 a Jury of Nashville, TN., declared that no
patent had been violated. I agree with this ruling because Alex and Ani’s
design is based on an expandable wire bracelet not a stretch metal bracelet
like R&L Merchandise.
Juicy
Couture Necklace Recall
My
last case deals with personal injury and wrongful death. It is based on a necklace
designed by Liz Claiborne for Juicy Couture. The necklace was said to contain
high levels of lead, which can cause poisoning and even be fatal. The necklace
was encrusted with jewels, charms and other juicy couture pieces. It was sold
in high-end department stores for around $95. On May 10, 2006 the Consumer
Product Safety Commission (CPSC) issued a recall for the item and offered
immediate assistance to anyone who had been harmed by the product. Luckily
there where no injuries and most importantly no lawsuits. I think this is a great
example for any jeweler because we tend to utilize some pretty crazy stuff
sometimes. Like the saying goes: “Everything that shines is not gold!”
References
http://www.nationaljeweler.com/nj/fashion/a/~15367-Settlement-reached-in-Pandora-patent
http://news.priorsmart.com/r-l-merchandise-v-alex-and-ani-l6WX/
http://www.pritzkerlaw.com/Liz_Claiborne_Recall/